Stockle - the stock oracle

MINES MANAGEMENT INC

US:MMGMWUS:MGN_old
No current share price held for this company.

Past year: ▲ 319%(22.2c – 1.40 USD)

Market cap
—
Shares on issue
—
Story beats
16 since 2004
Last event
27 Sept 2016

History

Mines Management spent a decade raising money to advance its Montanore silver-copper project in Montana, never reached production, and was bought by Hecla Mining in September 2016.

2004-2007: Listing and big raisings

Mines Management's securities were cleared for trading on the American Stock Exchange in March 2004. Its focus was the Montanore Silver-Copper Project in Montana. In October 2005 it sold 1,016,677 shares and five-year warrants (rights to buy 588,334 more shares at $8.50) to investors for $6.1 million.

The far larger raise came in April 2007, when TD Securities and four other underwriters sold 6,000,000 units at US$5.00, worth US$30 million before fees. Each unit held one share and half a warrant. In May the underwriters took up an extra 836,600 units, bringing the total to US$34,183,000 gross, or US$32,132,020 after commissions. The money was to fund a two-year advanced exploration and underground drilling program at Montanore, plus general needs.

In November 2007 Silver Wheaton Corp. bought 2,500,000 shares at US$4.00 (US$10 million), below the April price. It also received a twenty-year right of first proposal, and a right to match third-party offers, on silver the company produced in Montana.

2008-2011: Restatement and a funding gap

The record is quiet for 2008 and 2009. In March 2010 the Audit Committee concluded the 2008 accounts could no longer be relied on. Some Montanore exploration costs had been booked as property, plant and equipment when they should have been expensed, a point the SEC staff had questioned. The 2008 net loss rose from $10,306,637 to $10,768,116, and property, plant and equipment fell from $9,714,191 to $6,207,844.

In February 2011 the company released a Preliminary Economic Assessment, an early study of whether a project might pay. It put initial capital costs at $552.3 million (give or take 35%) and found favorable economic potential, but did not update the 2005 resource estimate of 81.5 million short tons, and the filing said it should not be relied on to value the project. A drilling program of about $20-25 million needed outside financing, and the company held $10.0 million in cash and securities at the end of 2010. On March 3, 2011 it agreed with Roth Capital Partners to sell 4,800,000 shares at $3.15, about $15.1 million gross, for permitting and drilling. Shares on issue rose from 23,342,097 at the end of 2010 to 28,739,110 at the end of 2011.

2012-2015: Quiet years and a listing warning

The record shows little for 2012 to 2014. In July 2015 the NYSE MKT warned that the company failed its continued-listing standards. Stockholders' equity was below the required levels, it had lost money in each of its last five fiscal years, and the exchange questioned whether it could keep operating and meet its obligations. A compliance plan was due by August 3, 2015. On September 21 the exchange accepted the plan, allowing until December 30, 2016 to meet the equity standards, though delisting remained possible. In October 2015 the company sold equipment to Amalgamated Mining for $1.25 million and $415,000.

2016: The Hecla merger

On May 24, 2016 the company announced that Hecla Mining Company would acquire it, with each share exchanged for 0.2218 of a Hecla share, a 41% premium to a 10-day average price. Hecla also lent it a $2.3 million secured term loan, backed by substantially all assets including Montanore. Series B preferred stock had been converting to common, and shares on issue ended 2016 at 36,118,970 on the feed.

The proxy statement set about 9,024,790 Hecla shares to be issued, leaving Mines Management holders with roughly 2.28% of Hecla. Shareholders approved the deal on September 12 and it closed on September 13, 2016. The company became a wholly owned Hecla subsidiary, all directors and officers resigned, and trading on the NYSE MKT was set to stop on September 14 and on the Toronto Stock Exchange after September 15. Its registration was terminated on September 27, 2016, ending its public reporting.

Written from the 16 story beats below (2004 to 27 Sept 2016), which come from the company's own announcements and filings.

Beat by beat

The events that changed the company's story, in plain English, each written against everything known about the company at the time. The dot shows whether it was good, bad or neutral for shareholders.

shares on issue market cap (log scale)

201636.1m shares · US$40.8m market cap

  1. 27 Sept

    MINES MANAGEMENT INC terminated the registration of a class of securities, ending its reporting obligation for them.

    listing compliance notice

    36.1m shUS$40.8m
  2. 14 Sept

    Shareholders approved the Hecla merger on September 12, 2016 and it closed on September 13: each Mines Management share became the right to 0.2218 of a Hecla share (cash for fractions), and the company is now a wholly owned Hecla subsidiary. Trading on the NYSE MKT is expected to be suspended September 14 and on the Toronto Stock Exchange to end after September 15, 2016, and all directors and officers (including the Dobbs and Nichole Altenburg) resigned. This ends the pending-merger thread and the NYSE MKT listing-deficiency issue, and is the end of independent public ownership of the company.

    business combination

    36.1m shUS$40.8m
  3. 14 Sept

    MINES MANAGEMENT INC's exchange filed to remove a class of its securities from listing.

    listing compliance notice

    36.1m shUS$40.8m
  4. 10 Aug

    The final proxy statement/prospectus set a shareholder vote for September 12, 2016 on the Hecla merger at a fixed ratio of 0.2218 Hecla share per Mines Management share (cash for fractions), with about 9,024,790 Hecla shares to be issued, leaving Mines Management holders with roughly 2.28% of Hecla. The board unanimously recommends approval; holders of about 17.6% of shares (including options) have agreed to vote in favor, approval needs a majority of votes cast, and Idaho law gives no appraisal rights. The ratio does not adjust for Hecla price moves, and Mines Management shares will stop being listed once the deal closes.

    business combination

    35.9m shUS$50.2m
  5. 27 May

    The formal merger agreement with Hecla (signed May 23, 2016) was filed: each Mines Management share becomes 0.2218 of a Hecla share, subject to a shareholder vote and SEC registration of the Hecla shares, and either side can terminate if the deal is not completed by August 15, 2016. Hecla also lent the company a $2.3 million secured term loan (LIBOR plus 5%), backed by substantially all assets including the Montanore Project, due by the earlier of August 15, 2016 or merger completion, and due immediately if the merger agreement ends for any reason other than a Hecla breach. The filing also shows amended severance terms for Glenn Dobbs, Douglas Dobbs and Nicole Altenburg (payable in stock at the company's option), a bylaw opting out of Idaho's control share law, and that Series B preferred stock has been converting into common (about 458 preferred shares left, convertible into about 582,500 common shares). This confirms the terms announced May 24 and adds the first debt the company has disclosed.

    business combination

    30.9m shUS$21.5m
  6. 24 May

    On May 24, 2016 Mines Management announced a merger agreement under which Hecla Mining Company, through its subsidiary HL Idaho Corp., would acquire it, with each Mines Management share exchanged for 0.2218 of a Hecla share. The release describes this as a 41% premium on a 10-day average price as of May 20, 2016, and expects closing in the third quarter of 2016, subject to a Mines Management shareholder vote and other conditions. Hecla intends to advance the Montanore evaluation program after closing. This is a proposed deal, not yet completed, so shareholders' treatment is not final.

    business combination

    30.9m shUS$21.5m

201529.8m shares · US$10.8m market cap

  1. 24 Sept

    On September 21, 2015 the NYSE MKT accepted the company's compliance plan. It gave until September 30, 2015 to regain compliance with the financial-impairment standard or show progress, and until December 30, 2016 for the three equity standards. Failure to make progress or regain compliance could still lead to delisting. This continues the July notice: delisting is postponed, not removed.

    listing compliance notice

    29.8m shUS$10.8m
  2. 8 July

    On July 1, 2015 the NYSE MKT told the company it fails continued-listing standards: stockholders' equity was below $2, $4 and $6 million at March 31, 2015, it had net losses in its five most recent fiscal years, and the exchange questioned whether it can continue operations and meet its obligations. The company must submit a compliance plan by August 3, 2015; if the plan is not submitted or accepted, delisting proceedings begin. This is a new threat to the company's exchange listing.

    listing compliance notice

    29.8m shUS$14.6m

201123.3m shares · US$81.2m market cap

  1. 3 Mar

    On March 3, 2011 the company agreed with Roth Capital Partners to sell 4,800,000 new shares at $3.15 each, for about $15.1 million gross and about $13.8 million net per the filing (the press release says about $14.2 million before offering expenses), with a 30-day option for 720,000 more shares. This is the additional financing the February update said was needed; the press release says proceeds are for Montanore permitting and the drilling program, and for general purposes. It adds shares, which dilutes existing holders, and the company and its officers and directors agreed not to sell shares for 90 days.

    material agreement

    23.3m shUS$81.2m
  2. 23 Feb

    The company gave an update on its 100%-owned Montanore project after finishing a Preliminary Economic Assessment (PEA). The PEA estimated initial capital costs of $552.3 million (±35%) and concluded the project has favorable economic potential justifying a resource evaluation program and pre-feasibility study; it did not update the 2005 resource estimate of 81.5 million short tons, and the filing says it should not be relied on to value the project. Permitting steps (supplemental draft EIS, biological opinion, 404 permit) are expected in 2011, with a Record of Decision possibly by end of 2011. The drilling program would cost about $20-25 million over about 18 months once permitting is done and needs external financing; 2011 cash use is estimated at $7.5 million against $10.0 million of cash and securities at December 31, 2010, which the company says must be augmented by additional financing in 2011. This sharpens the open funding question for the drilling program.

    resource reserve update

    23.3m shUS$71.0m

2010

  1. 31 Mar

    On March 25, 2010 the Audit Committee concluded the 2008 financial statements should no longer be relied on, because certain Montanore exploration costs previously recorded as property, plant and equipment should have been expensed. The SEC staff had questioned this treatment in reviewing the 2008 10-K. 2008 net loss rises from $10,306,637 to $10,768,116 ($0.48 per share) and property, plant and equipment falls from $9,714,191 to $6,207,844; the restatement will appear in the 2009 10-K.

    financial restatement

2007

  1. 5 Nov

    On November 2, 2007 the company sold 2,500,000 shares at US$4.00 (US$10 million) to Silver Wheaton Corp. in a private placement. It also granted Silver Wheaton a twenty-year right of first proposal and right to match third-party offers to buy silver the company produces in Montana, and agreed to register the shares for resale in the US. The price is below the US$5.00 paid in the April 2007 offering.

    capital raising announcement

  2. 10 May

    On May 9, 2007 the underwriters exercised their over-allotment option for 836,600 more units at US$5.00, adding US$4,183,000 gross. This brings the April 2007 offering to 6,836,600 units, US$34,183,000 gross and US$32,132,020 net of underwriting commissions; the press release says proceeds will fund part of a two-year advanced exploration and underground drilling program at the Montanore Silver-Copper Project in Montana and general corporate purposes.

    capital raising announcement

  3. 20 Apr

    On April 16, 2007 the company agreed with TD Securities and four other underwriters to sell 6,000,000 units at US$5.00 each (gross US$30,000,000, underwriters' fees US$1,800,000); the offering closed April 20, 2007. Each unit has one share plus half a warrant, with whole warrants exercisable at US$5.75 until April 19, 2012, and underwriters have a 30-day option for 900,000 more units. This is a much larger raise than the $6.1 million private placement of October 2005 and dilutes existing holders.

    material agreement

2005

  1. 24 Oct

    On October 21, 2005 the company sold 1,016,677 shares and five-year warrants for 588,334 more shares (exercise price $8.50) to accredited investors for $6,100,000 in total. It plans to use the money for general corporate purposes and agreed to file a registration statement so the investors can resell the shares; existing shareholders are diluted by the new shares and potential warrant shares.

    capital raising announcement

2004

  1. 23 Mar

    the American Stock Exchange certified MINES MANAGEMENT INC's securities for listing, clearing them to begin trading.

    listing compliance notice