Stockle - the stock oracle

LEGEND INTERNATIONAL HOLDINGS INC

US:LGDIQ
No current share price held for this company.
No price history held for this listing yet.
Market cap
—
Shares on issue
—
Story beats
28 since 2004
Last event
9 May 2016

History

Legend went from a Gutnick-controlled shell to a diamond, then phosphate explorer that raised $105m in 2008, but ended in Chapter 11 in 2016 after IFFCO's A$25m demand.

2004-2007: A shell under new control

In November 2004 Renika Pty Ltd, a trustee of a Gutnick family trust, bought about 88% of the company from founder Michael Tay and William Tay. Joseph Gutnick, an Australian mining-company director, became president, treasurer and sole director. Renika's holding, including an option, was 93.5% of 10,474,000 shares outstanding.

The first mining assets came in 2006. Legend agreed to buy diamond tenements (Calvert Hills and Cox projects) in the Northern Territory from Astro Diamond Mines N.L. for A$1.5 million. Gutnick was chairman of Astro and Dr D. S. Tyrwhitt, a Legend director, was also an Astro director, so it was a related-party deal. The purchase completed in July 2006.

Funding came from share placements. Renika received new shares on cashless exercises of options in 2005 and 2006, which added to the share count. A US$2 million placement at US$0.50 closed in September 2006, and further placements at that price raised US$2.6 million in total. Two one-for-two bonus issues, in November and December 2006, took the total to about 124 million shares. Between December 2006 and May 2007 further placements at about US$0.25 a share raised roughly US$5.4 million. In March 2007 a review of old reports found uranium and phosphate anomalies at Selby. These were historical results, and in May the company said it intended to spin off its uranium interests into a new public company.

2007-2008: The turn to phosphate

In December 2007 Legend sold 18,750,000 shares at US$0.80 to funds managed by Atticus Capital, raising US$15 million. The money was meant for a pre-feasibility study on phosphate deposits in Queensland's Georgina Basin. The company agreed to buy the Lady Annie, Lady Jane and Thorntonia areas from Iron Duyfken Pty Ltd, and D-Tree from Ansett Resources & Industries Pty Ltd. It also signed a deal letting King Eagle Resources earn 80% of phosphate on other tenements by spending $3 million over five years.

In June 2008 the company closed a placement of 42 million shares at US$2.50, raising US$105 million, led by BMO Capital Markets. It applied to list on the American Stock Exchange, though no listing is reported. In July 2008 India's IFFCO was given options over 30 million shares, worth $100.5 million if all were exercised. It also bought 15 million shares from a Gutnick affiliate, and was given two seats on an expanded six-member board. The parties agreed principles for IFFCO to take 4 million tonnes of phosphate rock a year.

2009-2011: Resources, studies and a partner

Drilling at D-Tree produced a first inferred resource of 135 million tonnes at 13.8% P2O5 (the phosphate content) in May 2009, with direct shipping ore production forecast for the fourth quarter of 2009. By September, results from Paradise North, formerly Lady Jane, made it the priority instead. The 2009 production start did not happen: in March 2010 the company said that Wengfu, a Chinese fertilizer producer allied with it since November 2009, had recommended waiting for a feasibility study.

That study was completed in June 2010. Its base case showed a pre-tax NPV (the present value of future cash flows) of US$1.5 billion and development capital of US$808 million. In February 2011 the company reported its first SEC-standard reserve, at Paradise South: 196.1 million tonnes of ore at 14.6% P2O5. An expanded study in April 2011 gave a pre-tax NPV of US$4.8 billion on capital of US$1,775 million. The company said a process run by Nomura had a shortlist of interested parties and expected to partner with a major fertilizer company within months. No partner was named. Queensland approved the Paradise North mining lease on April 12, 2011, after D-Tree North's lease in August 2010.

2012-2016: Small raisings and Chapter 11

No partner appeared in the record. In February 2012 Legend moved its phosphate tenements into a wholly-owned subsidiary, Paradise Phosphate Pty Ltd, to secure up to $7.5 million of convertible notes from two Australian funds. The notes were due in 12 months at a nominal 15% interest and were secured over the two mining leases. The outcome of the notes is not reported.

Two small private placements followed to one accredited investor each: 22,640,725 shares at US$0.10 in June 2012 (US$2.26 million) and 45 million shares at US$0.05 in February 2013 (US$2.25 million). The 2013 price was half the 2012 price. Shares on issue rose from about 226 million at the end of 2011 to 444 million at the end of 2013. The record is then quiet until 2016.

On March 29, 2016 IFFCO and its Dubai subsidiary Kisan International Trading demanded AUD$25,027,207.99 from Legend, then applied to wind it up under Australian law. Settlement talks failed. On May 8, 2016 Legend filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy in Delaware and said it would continue operating as a debtor-in-possession. As of that date, the filing did not say what would happen to shareholders' stock.

Written from the 28 story beats below (2004 to 9 May 2016), which come from the company's own announcements and filings.

Beat by beat

The events that changed the company's story, in plain English, each written against everything known about the company at the time. The dot shows whether it was good, bad or neutral for shareholders.

shares on issue market cap (log scale)

2016444m shares

  1. 9 May

    On May 8, 2016 Legend filed a voluntary Chapter 11 bankruptcy petition in Delaware and says it will keep running the business as a debtor-in-possession. The filing links this to a March 29, 2016 demand of AUD$25,027,207.99 from IFFCO and its Dubai subsidiary Kisan International Trading, followed by an IFFCO application to wind Legend up under Australian law, and failed settlement talks. IFFCO was the 2009 strategic investor with a Shareholders Agreement and options, so this is a breakdown of that relationship. The filing does not say what happens to shareholders' stock.

    bankruptcy or receivership

    444m sh

2013249m shares

  1. 21 Feb

    Effective February 18, 2013 the company sold 45,000,000 new shares at US$0.05 each to one accredited investor, raising US$2,250,000, in a private placement. The price is half the US$0.10 paid in the June 2012 placement, so existing holders are diluted more per dollar raised. The filing does not name the investor or state how the money will be used. The attached agreement also contains an inconsistency (its offering clause says US$0.10 while the subscription is at US$0.05).

    capital raising announcement

    249m sh

2012249m shares

  1. 6 July

    Effective June 29, 2012 the company sold 22,640,725 new shares at US$0.10 each to one accredited investor, raising US$2,264,072.50, in a private placement. This adds new shares for existing holders; the filing does not name the investor or say how the money will be used (the use is in a term sheet not included). Inference: the timing and size are close to Regals Fund's June 2012 rise to 18.80%, but the filing does not link them.

    capital raising announcement

    249m sh
  2. 16 Feb

    Effective February 7, 2012 the company agreed to transfer its phosphate tenements and related rights into a new wholly-owned subsidiary, Paradise Phosphate Pty Ltd, as required for up to $7.5 million of convertible notes from two Australian investment funds. The notes are due in 12 months at a nominal 15% interest and are secured by mortgages and charges over the two mining leases (ML 90190 and ML 90191), Paradise's assets and the Paradise shares. They convert into Paradise shares if Paradise lists on the ASX after raising about $20-30 million within 12 months; otherwise, or on a sale of the assets or of Paradise shares, the lenders are to be paid out. The filing says Legend's other assets are not available to the lenders. This is the first financing in the record, and it comes without the Wengfu or Nomura partnership flagged in 2010-11.

    debt financing

    226m sh

2011226m shares

  1. 15 Apr

    On April 12, 2011 Queensland approved the grant of the Paradise North mining lease ML90191, which was awaiting grant. The filing says it is the second mining lease for the project after D-Tree North's ML90190 (granted August 2010), and that Paradise North will be the first mining site. This resolves the open thread on mining lease grants.

    resource reserve update

    226m sh
  2. 13 Apr

    On April 8, 2011 the company reported results of the expanded Wengfu feasibility study (1.2 million tonnes a year of MAP/DAP), with pre-tax NPV of US$4.8 billion, pre-tax IRR of 27.9% and development capital of US$1,775 million. This is the expansion study that was due by end of Q3 2010. The base case NPV rose from US$1.5 billion to US$2.2 billion on higher CRU price forecasts. The company says a process run by Nomura has a shortlist of interested parties doing due diligence, and it expects to partner with a major fertilizer company 'in the coming months'; no partner or terms are named, and Wengfu's equity role is not mentioned.

    resource reserve update

    226m sh
  3. 1 Mar

    On February 24, 2011 the company reported its first SEC-standard reserve estimate, for Paradise South: 196.1 million tonnes of as-mined ore at 14.6% P2O5, and 55.5 million tonnes of recoverable phosphate rock concentrate at 33% P2O5. At 600,000 tonnes of DAP a year, the company says this supports about 59 years of operation, or 29 years at double the rate. This converts part of the earlier resource estimates into reserves, as the July 2010 study said would happen. The filing also says current DAP spot prices are above the US$445 per tonne long-term price assumed in the feasibility study.

    resource reserve update

    226m sh

2010

  1. 23 July

    On July 23, 2010 the company released the economics from the Wengfu feasibility study of the Paradise phosphate project, the study flagged in the March, May and June 2010 updates. The base case (600ktpa DAP/MAP, 15ktpa aluminium fluoride) shows US$11.0 billion revenue over 30 years, a pre-tax NPV of US$1.5 billion, a pre-tax IRR of 25.5%, and development capital of US$808 million with a 5-year payback. Wengfu will settle its equity role and help with financing after the expansion study due end of Q3 2010, and the company says other fertilizer companies have also approached it about investment; no financing is agreed. The resources used (81 Mt at 18.1% P2O5) are not SEC-defined reserves, and the filing says reserves are to be estimated later in 2010.

    resource reserve update

  2. 22 July

    On June 30, 2010 the company announced the Wengfu feasibility study was completed on time and on budget, concluding the project is 'positive and robust' against several fertilizer market scenarios. It covers a 600ktpa sulfuric acid plant, 300ktpa P2O5 phosphoric acid plant, 600ktpa DAP/MAP plant and 15ktpa aluminum fluoride plant, fed first by Paradise North ore and then a Paradise South beneficiation plant. No economics are given yet: details are promised July 23, 2010 with a New York meeting on July 26, and a second study on a 900ktpa P2O5 expansion is due end of Q3 2010. This delivers the study flagged in March and May.

    resource reserve update

  3. 18 May

    On May 10, 2010 the company reported a first inferred JORC resource for part of Paradise South (formerly Lady Annie) of 72 Mt at 17% P2O5, about 80% above the historical tonnage for that area (company was targeting around 40 Mt). It also signed non-binding MoUs with Mt Isa Mines (Xstrata) on sulphuric acid supply and with Coogee Chemicals on a possible sulphuric acid and storage joint venture, and signed native title and access agreements for the D-Tree North and Paradise North mining leases, now passed to Queensland for granting. The Wengfu feasibility study is said to be on track for completion in June. The filing notes inferred resources are highly uncertain and are not SEC reserves.

    resource reserve update

  4. 16 Mar

    On March 16, 2010 the company reported progress on its Queensland phosphate project. Wengfu (Group) Co. Ltd, a Chinese fertilizer producer allied with Legend since November 2009, gave positive initial findings, and the company will become an equity partner after a positive feasibility study (due Q2 2010). Wengfu recommended deferring the decision to mine and ship direct shipping ore until that study is done, so the Q4 2009 DSO start flagged earlier has not happened and the timeline will be reissued. The filing also gives a first Paradise North resource estimate of 7.3 Mt at 28.1% P2O5 for the drilled central core, and says land of over 740 acres has been reserved near Mt Isa for a phosphoric acid plant. It restates the intent to spin out the diamond, gold and base metal interests to shareholders pro rata, leaving a pure phosphate company; no terms are given. IFFCO is described as still willing to take rock and fertiliser products.

    resource reserve update

2009

  1. 24 Sept

    On September 24, 2009 the company reported first drill results from Paradise North (formerly Lady Jane): results for 45 of 108 holes, 33 with intercepts above 10% P2O5, and several thick (~7m) intercepts above 30% P2O5 under about 12m of overburden. It says the Paradise North mining lease application (MLA 90191) got a 'No-EIS' decision, a pilot beneficiation plant started operating, and Ausenco Minerals was awarded a bankable feasibility study for a 1 Mtpa beneficiation plant. The filing says Paradise North should now be the priority for direct shipping ore, a change from the D-Tree-first plan with Q4 2009 production told earlier, and that this also affects the DSO timeline (the text is truncated, so the new timeline is not shown). A resource estimate is promised by end of 2009, and the filing says the historical estimate is not an SEC-defined reserve. Paradise South was granted August 28, 2009 and drilling there is planned from October 2009.

    resource reserve update

  2. 14 May

    On May 14, 2009 the company announced a first inferred JORC resource at D-Tree of 135 Mt at 13.8% P2O5, bringing the combined D-Tree and D-Tree West total to 305 Mt at 15% P2O5. It says its D-Tree direct shipping ore project is on schedule to start production in Q4 2009, with forecast operating cost of A$100-125 per tonne FOB Townsville and capital cost of A$10-15 million. This delivers the resource estimate promised in February, though the filing warns inferred resources are highly uncertain and are not SEC reserves.

    resource reserve update

  3. 25 Feb

    On February 25, 2009 the company reported drilling results at its D-Tree phosphate project: results back for 470 of 476 holes, with over 250 holes showing intercepts above 8% P2O5. A formal JORC-standard resource estimate is promised by the end of March 2009. The filing states the historical estimate is not an SEC-defined reserve, and that Legend holds 80% of the D-Tree tenements under a heads of agreement with Mt Isa Metals Ltd. It also expects permits for the Lady Annie project in the third quarter of 2009. This follows up the D-Tree purchase and the phosphate push.

    resource reserve update

2008

  1. 16 July

    On July 14, 2008 the company gave India's IFFCO options over 30 million shares (5m at $2.50 expiring in 60 days, 8m at $3.00, 8m at $3.50, 9m at $4.00), worth $100.5 million if all exercised. The parties also agreed principles for a long-term deal for IFFCO to take 4 million tonnes of phosphate rock a year at a discount of at least 5% to a benchmark price, to be negotiated within 9 months of closing and not binding if not signed within 24 months. Separately IFFCO bought 15 million shares from a Joseph Gutnick affiliate at $1.87; the board is to grow from two to six members with two IFFCO nominees, and some material actions will need unanimous board approval. Exercise of the options would dilute holders, and IFFCO becomes a major shareholder with board influence.

    capital raising announcement

  2. 5 June

    The private placement closed on June 3-4, 2008, upsized by US$5 million: 42 million shares were issued at US$2.50 for US$105 million, and agents received 840,000 warrants at US$2.50 exercisable to June 3, 2010. Proceeds are for the Queensland phosphate projects and working capital; the company will register the shares and warrant shares, and has applied to list on the American Stock Exchange. This completes the raise announced on May 22, and adds to the share count.

    capital raising announcement

  3. 27 May

    On May 22, 2008 the company announced an agreement to raise US$100 million by issuing 40 million shares at US$2.50 each, in a private placement led by BMO Capital Markets with 25 institutional investors. The money is for the Georgina Basin phosphate projects in Queensland, and the company will register the shares for resale. This is far above the US$0.80 paid by Atticus in December 2007 and will add many new shares, diluting existing holders.

    capital raising announcement

2007

  1. 28 Dec

    On December 7, 2007 the company signed a heads of agreement with King Eagle Resources Pty Limited letting it earn an 80% interest in phosphate on three Queensland tenement blocks (Quita Creek, Highland Plains, Lily and Sherrin Creek) by spending $3 million on exploration over five years, with at least $200,000 in year 1 before any withdrawal. Legend gets no rights to other minerals, and the press release cites historical, not verified, estimates of 1,463 million tonnes at 16.0% P2O5 across all its phosphate holdings. This extends the phosphate push in the Georgina Basin.

    material agreement

  2. 28 Dec

    The company reported agreements to acquire phosphate project areas in Queensland's Georgina Basin: Lady Annie, Lady Jane and Thorntonia from Iron Duyfken Pty Ltd (A$500,000 plus 500,000 shares, effective November 2, 2007) and D-Tree from Ansett Resources & Industries Pty Ltd (A$300,000, effective November 7, 2007). Under the Iron Duyfken deal the permits are applications held in trust for Legend, and Iron Duyfken keeps the uranium rights. It also reported small share issues: 75,000 shares on a cashless exercise of 90,000 options and 104,000 shares for investor relations and consulting. This adds a phosphate business alongside the diamond and uranium work and is the use the December US$15m raise was earmarked for.

    capital raising announcement

  3. 19 Dec

    The company sold 18,750,000 new shares at US$0.80 each to funds managed by Atticus Capital, raising US$15,000,000 in a private placement effective December 12, 2007, and agreed to register the shares for resale. The press release says the money is to fund a pre-feasibility study on historic phosphate deposits at D Tree, Lady Annie, Lady Jane and Thorntonia in Queensland. This is far above the earlier US$0.25 placements and adds to the share count, diluting existing holders.

    capital raising announcement

  4. 14 May

    The company issued 18,470,000 more restricted shares raising US$4,117,500 and says it has closed its US$0.25 private placements. It plans to file a Form SB-2 within 45 days to register shares, and announced an intention to spin off its uranium exploration interests into a new public company, with shares distributed to existing Legend holders as a dividend once an SEC registration is effective. No record date or terms are given yet; this follows the Selby uranium anomalies reported in March.

    capital raising announcement

  5. 28 Mar

    From December 31, 2006 to March 28, 2007 the company issued 5,315,624 restricted shares raising US$1,328,906 (about US$0.25 each, inference from the amounts) for exploration and working capital, and about 41,934,337 bonus shares were issued for the second one-for-two bonus. It also reports drilling and sampling in Abner Range, and says a review of old reports found radioactive phosphate and uranium anomalies at Selby (past assays 250 to 532 ppm uranium); further work is planned, but these are historical results, not new findings.

    capital raising announcement

2006

  1. 13 Dec

    Placements at US$0.50 total 5,201,657 shares raising US$2,600,828, all received. About 27,574,721 bonus shares were issued on November 17, 2006, leaving roughly 82,724,163 shares outstanding, and 400,000 more options at US$2.25 were agreed. Stockholders approved the increase in authorized shares to 200 million, and a second one-for-two bonus issue is set for a December 31, 2006 record date, taking the total to about 124,086,244. Drilling is also due to start at the Glyde River project (next to the Merlin diamond mine) and Abner Range.

    capital raising announcement

  2. 6 Oct

    The company completed the US$2,000,000 placement (4,000,000 shares at US$0.50) on September 18, 2006, resolving the delays; about US$1.2m had already been received and used to complete the Astro tenement purchase, with the rest for diamond exploration and working capital. It also adopted a 2006 stock option plan and granted options (Gutnick 1,000,000 at US$2.25; Peter Lee 700,000, half at US$1.00 and half at US$2.25), and announced a one-for-two bonus share issue (record date November 17, 2006) plus a plan to double authorized shares to 200 million and make another one-for-two bonus issue. Bonus issues give existing holders more shares but are not described as adding value; the option grants add potential dilution (inference).

    capital raising announcement

  3. 24 July

    The company completed the purchase of the Astro diamond tenements (Calvert Hills and Cox) on July 21, 2006, finishing the March 2006 agreement. It also issued 31,880,035 restricted shares to Renika on a cashless exercise of 34,778,220 options, and announced a placement of 4,000,000 shares at US$0.50 (US$2,000,000) to fund diamond exploration and working capital, due to complete August 15, 2006. The share issues add to shares outstanding (inference: dilution of non-Renika holders).

    asset acquisition disposition

  4. 10 Mar

    The company agreed to buy diamond mining tenements in the Northern Territory (Calvert Hills and Cox projects) from Astro Diamond Mines N.L. for A$1.5 million, payable 90 days after Astro shareholders approve, with a meeting expected in April 2006. Gutnick is chairman and managing director of Astro, and director Dr D. S. Tyrwhitt is also an Astro director, so this is a deal with related parties; the price follows a valuation prepared for Astro. This is the first mining asset in the company's history.

    material agreement

2005

  1. 15 Sept

    The company issued 7,593,750 shares of common stock to Renika Pty Ltd, the Gutnick-linked controlling holder, on a cashless exercise of 9,000,000 options. No cash proceeds are reported, and the extra shares add to the number outstanding, which was 10,474,000 in late 2004 (inference: this raises Renika's stake and dilutes other holders).

    capital raising announcement

2004

  1. 24 Nov

    Control of the company changed: on November 17, 2004 Renika Pty Ltd, a trustee of a Gutnick family trust, bought 9,217,120 shares (about 88%) from founder Michael Tay and William Tay under an October 25, 2004 agreement, plus an option on 578,240 more. The Tays resigned and Joseph Gutnick, an Australian mining-company director, became president, treasurer and sole director; Renika's holding including the option is 93.5%, with 10,474,000 shares outstanding. This replaces the Tay-controlled era in the earlier history.

    business combination