Stockle - the stock oracle

East Energy Resources Limited

ASX:EER
A$0.036Latest close held · delayed

Past year: ▲ 0%(3.60c – 3.60c AUD)

Market cap
A$115m
Shares on issue
3.20bn
Story beats
53 since 2007
Last event
19 Sept 2022

History

A Queensland thermal coal explorer grew a 3.44 billion tonne resource but, after Noble Group's debt conversion and years of suspension, was removed from the ASX in September 2022.

2007-2009: Listing and the Blackall find

East Energy Resources listed in December 2007 after an IPO of 18 million shares at 25 cents, raising $4.5 million. It held two Queensland coal projects, Norwich Park and Blackall, bought from vendors linked to its chairman and managing director. Shares on issue were 22.3 million at the end of 2008.

Blackall became the focus. In January 2008 old 1974 data suggested a non-JORC (not formally verified) target of 79 to 90 million tonnes. The exploration licence was granted in May 2008, drilling began in June, and coal turned up in 94% of the first-phase holes. The company raised its target to over 200 million tonnes in August and 500 to 550 million tonnes in November. In April 2009 it announced a maiden JORC resource of about 1.2 billion tonnes, rated Inferred (the least certain category).

Money was harder to find. A 2009 rights issue aimed at about $8.9 million raised only $3.8 million, from 38.1 million shares at 10 cents. Chairman Terence Byrt resigned in April, and Mark Basso became Executive Chairman in August. In October a 16-hole program at Capella found no coal, so the company dropped that tenement. Executive director Clive Triplett left in November.

2010-2012: Noble Group arrives

Northern drilling in 2010 showed coal continuing north, adding about 14 kilometres of strike length, and management said the resource could exceed 2.0 billion tonnes. In May a subsidiary of Singapore-listed Noble Group bought 19.99% of the company, its first major strategic shareholder. Noble executive Rex Littlewood joined the board in July. Bulk sample tests in October gave a washed yield of about 70%.

Options were exercised in early 2011, raising $7.569 million through 37.8 million new shares and lifting shares on issue to 166.4 million. The money went to the Blackall mining licence application, studies and exploration. A May 2011 JORC resource showed 469 million tonnes Indicated (a firmer category) within 749 million tonnes. The full report in June gave 459 million tonnes Indicated; the text does not explain the difference. The licence application was lodged in June 2011.

In September 2012 a new SRK resource put Blackall at 1.74 billion tonnes: 627 million Indicated and 1,113 million Inferred. Days later the company signed a secured facility of up to $5.5 million with Idalia Coal, 50.1% owned by a Noble subsidiary.

2013-2015: Buying Idalia

In January 2013 EER agreed to buy its own lender, Idalia Coal, from Noble and Majicyl for shares valued at 20 cents, against a market price of 10 cents. Idalia added a 440 million tonne Inferred resource and adjacent tenements. Shareholders voted in May, and 190.0 million shares were issued at 20 cents ($38.0 million). Noble then held 40.93% and Majicyl 45.87%. Noble also refinanced $13.48 million of debt over five years.

Cash was thin: about $192,000 at September 2013, with up to about $4.9 million of Noble loan available. In July 2014 the EPC 1399 resource was updated to 1,504 million tonnes, lifting the combined Blackall total to 3.44 billion tonnes. Mining Development Licence 464 was granted from August 2014. In March 2015 the regulator combined all tenements, now 3,580 square kilometres, under Project Status, allowing lower exploration spend to conserve cash in the coal downturn. Shares traded at 1 cent.

2016-2019: The Noble dispute and dilution

The record for 2016 and early 2017 is quiet. In September 2017 EER suspended trading over a dispute with Noble about drawdown requests under the 2013 facility, saying it was critical to solvency. In November Noble advanced $500,000 and the facility was restructured, bringing forward Noble's right to convert debt to shares.

Shareholders approved conversion in May 2018. Chris Thoroughgood joined the board, founder Mark Basso-Brusa resigned after 11 years, and Littlewood became Managing Director and Chairman. In June 2018 Noble's $27.02 million of debt converted at $0.0095 into 2,844,506,105 shares, issued to its subsidiary Maylion. Shares on issue rose from about 356 million to 3.2 billion, heavily diluting other holders. In January 2019 EER signed an A$1.355 million loan with Noble Trading Co at 9.8%, as Noble now owned 93.42%.

2020-2021: Suspension and a change of owner

A further A$500,000 Noble loan was signed in January 2020, and MDL 464 was renewed to July 2024. In September 2020, after the price rose from $0.004 to a high of $0.036, EER said it was discussing a possible recapitalisation and its controlling holding, and its shares were suspended.

In December 2020 Noble Netherlands agreed to sell Maylion to Axis Minerals. Shareholders approved on 21 May 2021 and it settled on 28 May. James Newbury became Executive Chairman and Managing Director, and Littlewood and Thoroughgood resigned. Noble's debt of $1.855 million plus interest was forgiven, and the year to June 2021 showed a profit of $8.17 million against a $7.14 million loss. In October 2021 EER engaged GOMAC Projects for a concept study on converting Blackall coal into gas, hydrogen, fertiliser and other products.

2021-2022: Delisting

In December 2021 three directors resigned, and EER borrowed A$200,000 interest-free from Cavalier Corporate, owned by director Ranko Matic. A further A$100,000 came from Cataalna Pty Ltd, also controlled by Matic, in May 2022, after cash fell to $3,000. The GOMAC study stalled for lack of funds.

By 30 June 2022 cash was $30,000. Annual listing fees went unpaid, and ASX removed EER from the official list on 19 September 2022 after two years of continuous suspension. Maylion held about 93.4%. The recapitalisation was never announced as completed, and the record does not say what happens to holders' shares.

Written from the 53 story beats below (2007 to 19 Sept 2022), which come from the company's own announcements and filings.

Beat by beat

The events that changed the company's story, in plain English, each written against everything known about the company at the time. The dot shows whether it was good, bad or neutral for shareholders.

shares on issue market cap (log scale)

20223.20bn shares · A$115m market cap

  1. 19 Sept

    ASX removed EER from the official list from 19 September 2022, after its shares had been suspended for a continuous two years. The recapitalisation EER was pursuing is not mentioned, and the text does not say what happens to holders' shares.

    listing compliance notice

    3.20bn shA$115m
  2. 22 Aug

    ASX listed EER among entities that failed to pay annual listing fees for the year to 30 June 2023; its shares were already suspended. Unpaid fees by 26 August 2022 would lead to removal from the official list.

    listing compliance notice

    3.20bn shA$115m
  3. 16 May

    EER secured a second A$100,000 unsecured, interest-free, on-demand loan, from Cataalna Pty Ltd, controlled by director Ranko Matic (related party). It funds working capital and compliance while recapitalisation is pursued, after cash fell to $3,000.

    debt financing

    3.20bn shA$115m

20213.20bn shares · A$115m market cap

  1. 20 Dec

    Executive director Grant Ferguson and non-executive directors Stephen Ross and Alastair Smith resigned effective immediately. The text gives no reason. Only a few months after the May board build-out, this shrinks the board.

    director officer appointment

    3.20bn shA$115m
  2. 2 Dec

    EER secured an A$200,000 unsecured, interest-free loan repayable on demand from Cavalier Corporate, owned by director Ranko Matic (a related party). Funds are for working capital and compliance costs, replacing the Noble loans cleared in May.

    debt financing

    3.20bn shA$115m
  3. 6 Oct

    EER engaged GOMAC Projects to run a concept study on turning the Blackall coal into gas, hydrogen, fertiliser, power, liquids or chemicals, all with carbon capture. This is a new direction for the 3.44Bt resource. EER will talk to ASX about reinstatement conditions.

    material agreement

    3.20bn shA$115m
  4. 5 Aug

    Year to 30 June 2021 shows a profit of $8,174,098 versus a $7,141,983 loss. The Noble debt of $1.855m plus accrued interest was forgiven on 28 May under the Axis share sale deal (the text does not link it to the profit; inference). Still suspended.

    annual report

    3.20bn shA$115m
  5. 29 July

    June 2021 quarter: shareholders approved the Axis Minerals purchase of Noble's stake on 21 May and it settled 28 May, resolving that thread. No field work; cash fell to $160,000, about 0.79 quarters of funding. Recapitalisation work continues and the suspension runs to August.

    quarterly activities report

    3.20bn shA$115m
  6. 28 May

    After the Axis takeover of the controlling stake, James Newbury became Executive Chairman and MD on $360,000 a year. Bryan Duncan and Grant Ferguson became executive directors ($240,000 each) and Stephen Ross a non-executive director. Littlewood and Thoroughgood resigned; pay is subject to capital being raised.

    director officer appointment

    3.20bn shA$115m
  7. 28 Jan

    December 2020 quarter: on 30 December, Noble Netherlands agreed to sell Maylion (2,990,419,558 EER shares) to Axis Minerals, an unrelated company, subject to shareholder approval. EPC 1403 surrender completed. Suspension extended to 31 March 2021.

    quarterly activities report

    3.20bn shA$115m

20203.20bn shares · A$12.8m market cap

  1. 17 Sept

    At EER's request, trading was suspended while it discusses a possible recapitalisation and its controlling shareholder's (Noble/Maylion) holding. Suspension expected to last until 19 October 2020 or an earlier announcement. The company says its future direction is uncertain.

    listing compliance notice

    3.20bn shA$12.8m
  2. 17 Sept

    After the price rose from $0.004 to an intraday high of $0.036, EER told ASX it is aware of unannounced information about a possible recapitalisation transaction. It cannot disclose yet because talks are confidential and incomplete.

    price query

    3.20bn shA$12.8m
  3. 30 Jan

    December 2019 quarter: MDL 464 renewed for five years to July 2024 and EPC 1398 for three years to June 2022, resolving both renewal threads. No field work. The A$500,000 Noble loan was signed after quarter end.

    quarterly activities report

    3.20bn shA$9.6m
  4. 10 Jan

    EER signed a new A$500,000 loan with Noble Trading Co for working capital: 9.8% interest, repayable in three years, unsecured. This adds to the A$1.355m loan and continues reliance on its 93.42% owner.

    debt financing

    3.20bn shA$9.6m

20193.20bn shares · A$6.4m market cap

  1. 31 Jan

    EER signed an A$1.355m loan with Noble Trading Co: 9.8% interest, repayable in three years, unsecured. It repays the A$400,000 advance and keeps A$955,000 for working capital and Blackall. This continues EER's reliance on Noble, now its 93.42% owner.

    debt financing

    3.20bn shA$6.4m

20183.20bn shares · A$19.2m market cap

  1. 31 July

    June 2018 quarter: Noble's $27.02m debt converted at $0.0095 into 2,844,506,105 new shares, issued 22 June 2018 to Noble's subsidiary Maylion. Shares on issue rose from about 356m to 3.2bn, heavily diluting existing holders. EPC 1149 was renewed to April 2023. This resolves the conversion thread.

    quarterly activities report

    3.20bn shA$19.2m
  2. 25 May

    Noble's Chris Thoroughgood joins the board and founding director Mark Basso-Brusa resigns after 11 years. Noble's Rex Littlewood becomes Managing Director and Chairman on $145,250 a year. Shareholders approved the debt conversion at the 23 May meeting, though Noble had not yet converted.

    director officer appointment

    356m shA$1.1m

2017356m shares · A$3.6m market cap

  1. 24 Nov

    Resolves the Noble dispute: Noble advanced $500,000 and the facility was restructured. Noble's debt-to-equity conversion rights are brought forward, with a shareholder meeting planned early 2018. After conversion, current officers resign and Noble appoints three. Likely dilution for shareholders (inference).

    debt financing

    356m shA$3.6m
  2. 29 Sept

    EER requested a voluntary trading suspension because it is in dispute with lender Noble over drawdown requests under the 2013 facility. Noble disputed the second request and has not paid the first. The company says failure to resolve this is critical to its solvency.

    other

    356m shA$3.6m

2015356m shares · A$5.3m market cap

  1. 26 Mar

    Regulator approved EER's November variation, combining all Idalia and East Energy tenements (now 3,580 sq km) under Project Status and allowing lower exploration spend. Resource unchanged at 3.44Bt. Management says it conserves cash during the coal downturn. Shares 1c.

    regulatory community update

    356m shA$5.3m

2014356m shares · A$18.5m market cap

  1. 1 Aug

    June quarter: MDL 464 was granted for five years from 1 August 2014, resolving the long-pending application. The EPC 1399 resource of 1,504Mt was released, and the regulator approved Project Status for five tenements. Shares 4.4c.

    quarterly activities report

    356m shA$18.5m
  2. 10 July

    EPC 1399 resource updated to 1,504Mt Inferred (JORC 2012), lifting Blackall's combined total to 3.44Bt. The earlier 440Mt Idalia figure is superseded for 1399; EPC 1398 stays at 200Mt. A new 2.0-2.5Bt exploration target is also reported. Shares 2c.

    resource reserve update

    356m shA$18.5m

2013190m shares · A$9.9m market cap

  1. 31 Oct

    September quarter: drilling on Idalia's EPC 1399 finished and resource modelling targets year-end. Cash is only about $192,000, with up to about $4.9m of Noble loan available. Queensland proposes to grant the MDL. Board is assessing timing of more project funding given coal markets and reviewing new projects.

    quarterly activities report

    190m shA$9.9m
  2. 10 May

    Idalia acquisition completed 10 May after the 3 May shareholder vote. 190.0m shares issued at 20c ($38.0m, adjusted from $40m); Noble now holds 40.93%, Majicyl 45.87%. Noble refinancing of $13.48m over 5 years; about $5m left to draw. Shares on issue 356.5m.

    business combination

    190m shA$13.3m
  3. 20 Mar

    EER signed the formal share purchase agreement for Idalia: $40m in shares at 20c, with Noble then holding 41.18% and Majicyl 45.98%. Noble will refinance the debt over 5 years at bank bill rate plus 7%, leaving $5-6m to draw. Shareholder vote is due in April.

    material agreement

    166m shA$14.5m
  4. 23 Jan

    EER signed a binding heads of agreement to buy 100% of Idalia Coal, its own lender, from Noble and Majicyl for $40m of EER shares at 20c, versus a 10c market price. Adds a 440Mt Inferred resource and a 4.0-4.5Bt exploration target in adjacent tenements.

    business combination

    166m shA$12.5m

2012166m shares · A$18.3m market cap

  1. 27 Sept

    EER signed a 4-year secured facility of up to $5.5m with Idalia Coal, 50.1% owned by a Noble Group subsidiary. $2.5m is available immediately, then $1m a year for three years. Interest is bank bill rate plus 7.5%; security needs shareholder approval at the November AGM.

    debt financing

    166m shA$18.3m
  2. 17 Sept

    SRK's new JORC resource for Blackall is 1.74Bt: 627Mt Indicated and 1,113Mt Inferred, to 150m depth. That is about 1Bt above the 2011 figure of 749Mt, and resolves the long-delayed combined report. The 1.8-2.0Bt target is not yet fully covered.

    resource reserve update

    166m shA$18.3m
  3. 31 Jan

    December quarter: SRK's data review recommended 22 more infill holes, 14 of them drilled at Carlow. EER set a 2.0Bt in-situ coal target for the whole tenement. A single combined JORC report is now due in first half 2012, later than previously flagged.

    quarterly activities report

    166m shA$34.1m

2011166m shares · A$68.2m market cap

  1. 7 June

    Full Xenith resource report released, showing 459Mt Indicated for southern Blackall (the April announcement said 469Mt; the text does not explain the difference). The Mineral Development Licence application has been lodged, with approval expected in 6 to 12 months.

    resource reserve update

    166m shA$68.2m
  2. 2 May

    Maiden JORC Indicated resource of 469Mt at Blackall's Carlow deposit, within a total of 749Mt, covering about 15% of the tenement to 150m depth. This is a smaller, firmer figure than the earlier 1.2Bt Inferred; MDL application to follow.

    resource reserve update

    166m shA$97.4m
  3. 8 Apr

    Option exercise at 20c raised $7.569m through 37.8m new shares; Noble converted all 25m of its options. Shares on issue rise to 166.4m. Funds are for the Blackall mining licence application, scoping studies and northern exploration. Resolves the March option deadline.

    capital raising announcement

    166m shA$41.6m

2010132m shares · A$25.0m market cap

  1. 19 Oct

    Noble's Osendo is to receive up to 30 million 20c options from Mark Basso's Majicyl for nil. If shareholders approve at the November AGM, Osendo exercises 12.5m options for $2.5m, for a Blackall mining licence. Up to $3.5m more is possible by March 2011.

    material agreement

    132m shA$25.0m
  2. 8 Oct

    Washability tests on the 350kg Blackall bulk sample gave a washed coal yield of about 70% and 6,755 kcal/kg calorific value, with low sulphur. This was the awaited result; management calls it encouraging, and further lab tests continue.

    drilling result

    132m shA$25.0m
  3. 20 July

    Noble Group executive Rex Littlewood joins as Non-Executive Director, with Will Randall as alternate, following Noble's 19.9% stake bought in April 2010. The board returns to four directors after Clive Triplett's departure.

    director officer appointment

    129m shA$20.0m
  4. 3 May

    East Energy welcomed Osendo Pty Ltd, a subsidiary of Singapore-listed Noble Group, buying a 19.99% stake. Noble is said to have coal mining and marketing experience that could help plan Blackall. First major strategic shareholder.

    asset acquisition disposition

    22.3m shA$6.6m
  5. 8 Apr

    Eighteen northern holes show coal seams continuing north, adding about 14km of strike length, with fresh coal at 12-15m. Management says the resource could conceivably exceed 2.0 billion tonnes, up from 1.2 billion, subject to detailed evaluation.

    drilling result

    22.3m shA$2.2m
  6. 30 Mar

    Northern Blackall drilling began after a delay from January-February floods. The first eight holes hit coal seams continuing from the south, so the program grew from 12 to 20 holes. SRK is to use the data to extend the 1.2 billion tonne Inferred resource.

    drilling result

    22.3m shA$2.0m

200922.3m shares · A$2.5m market cap

  1. 27 Nov

    Executive Director Clive Triplett, a founder involved in the December 2007 listing, resigned immediately, saying he must commit fully to RMA Energy, where he is Managing Director. Board changes will be announced shortly.

    director officer appointment

    22.3m shA$2.5m
  2. 27 Oct

    The 16-hole Capella program (100-150m deep, about 4km apart) hit no coal. The board will drop the Capella tenement (EPC 1066) and refocus on Blackall, aiming to upgrade the 1.2 billion tonne Inferred resource to Indicated.

    drilling result

    22.3m shA$3.3m
  3. 25 Aug

    Managing director Mark Basso was appointed Executive Chairman, filling the seat left by Terence Byrt's April resignation. The release also welcomes Hancock's proposed 510km private rail line and port, which the company says would help its 1.2 billion tonne Blackall project.

    director officer appointment

    22.3m shA$3.0m
  4. 12 May

    The rights issue closed having raised $3,813,235 from 38,132,347 new shares at 10c, with 76,264,694 free options at 20c. That is well under the roughly $8.9m possible if fully subscribed. Shares and options were due to be issued 15 May.

    capital raising announcement

    22.3m shA$2.3m
  5. 23 Apr

    Headline confirms a 1.2 billion tonne maiden resource for the Blackall project, the JORC resource guided since 2008. The body text is mostly unreadable, so detail comes from later reports: an Inferred figure of about 1,222Mt, due to the delay to April.

    resource reserve update

    22.3m shA$3.1m
  6. 21 Apr

    Chairman Terence Byrt, a director since before the 2007 listing, resigned from the board effective immediately. The board does not intend to replace him and will name a current director to chair meetings as needed.

    director officer appointment

    22.3m shA$3.1m
  7. 8 Apr

    Letter on the rights issue announced 6 April: 1 new share at 10c per share held, with 2 free options at 20c expiring 31 March 2011. Fully subscribed it would raise about $8.9m, not underwritten, to fund Norwich Park and more Blackall drilling.

    capital raising announcement

    22.3m shA$3.1m

200822.3m shares · A$5.1m market cap

  1. 24 Nov

    Company lifts its non-JORC Blackall target to 500-550Mt from 200-220Mt after over 200 RAB and 40 core holes; 2008 drilling is complete. Company says this is conceptual; a JORC resource is due in early 2009.

    resource reserve update

    22.3m shA$5.1m
  2. 27 Aug

    Blackall non-JORC mineralisation target raised from 79-90Mt to over 200Mt of thermal coal after stage one drilling. Over 130 RAB holes and 8 core holes done; a JORC resource is expected early next year.

    resource reserve update

  3. 28 July

    First-phase Blackall drilling finished: 35 RAB holes (2,946m) to 30 June, with coal in 94% of holes and average cumulative seam thickness over 3m. Company believes the 79-90Mt non-JORC target can grow; stage two will add coring.

    drilling result

  4. 18 June

    Drilling began at Blackall on 12 June 2008 with the first rig; all five RAB holes so far intersected coal seams. Starts the programme aimed at a JORC resource, with no grades or thicknesses reported yet.

    drilling spud

  5. 12 May

    Blackall exploration licence (EPC 1149) granted for five years over about 867 square kilometres. Resolves the pending grant; drilling is planned within months to try to confirm a JORC resource beyond the non-JORC 79-90 million tonne target.

    regulatory community update

  6. 22 Jan

    Due diligence on 1974 historical data gives a non-JORC 'mineralisation target' of 79 to 90 million tonnes of thermal coal at Blackall. It is conceptual only and needs verification before any resource can be stated.

    resource reserve update

2007

  1. 19 Dec

    The $4.5 million IPO (18 million shares at 25c) closed fully subscribed, with ASX listing tentatively set for 19 December 2007. Funds go to exploration, including 10,000 metres of planned drilling at Norwich Park.

    capital raising announcement

  2. 16 Nov

    Prospectus for an IPO of 18,000,000 shares at 25 cents each to raise $4.5 million. The new coal explorer holds two Queensland projects, Norwich Park and Blackall, acquired from its chairman's and managing director's associated vendors.

    capital raising announcement